« archives

February 2008
S M T W T F S
« Jan   Apr »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
242526272829  

recently

news from around the web

» view all

Linux, take 14 (Ubuntu 7.10 Review)

February 15th 2008

I’ve had an on-and-off relationship with Linux for the past 10 years. It all started with RedHat 5.2, which I got on a CD that came with a book (because it would have taken 3 days to download on the old 56k modem, and I thought the book was a good way to start). Now, just to clarify, I was thirteen at the time.

It took me a while, but after about a week of tweaking, recompiling the kernel, finding a stable driver for my 10MBps network card, and making X work with my video card, it finally was up and running. Just the installation taught me a ton about computers, hardware, Linux, and problem solving skills that would surely help me in the future.

But I couldn’t really use it after that. I spent maybe 6 months with it installed as a dual-boot with Windows 98, but there just weren’t good replacements for my daily desktop apps back then—no games, no web development software (I used Dreamweaver back then… shudder), none of those little tools I had come to rely on in Windows. Like writing a journal, my Linux use stagnated and I eventually deleted the partition to make room for more games.

I went through 5-10 distros in all after that, maybe once a year I’d give it another shot. I tried RedHat again, Fedora, Gentoo, Mandrake, Debian, Gentoo again, and then Ubuntu. I’ve installed or used Ubuntu exclusively for the last few years (I’ll explain my reasons later) and I’ve enjoyed it for the most part.

Last week, I installed Ubuntu 7.10, Gutsy Gibbon. I also had an epiphany that the names of Ubuntu releases are in alphabetical order (Dapper, Edgy, Feisty, Gutsy) and I was no longer confused. Hooray.

The verdict: We’ve come a long way. Installation not only took minutes, but found all of my hardware without trouble, including enabling all 3D functions of my graphics card and detecting an obscure USB WiFi adapter. I am impressed thus far.

I experienced some instability after that, mainly when rotating the 3D desktop cube (amazing) and watching 6 movies at once (six times more amazing) in Mplayer. OK, maybe I went a little overboard, but a crash is a crash nonetheless. Turned out that updating the nVidia drivers (to version 169.09, if anyone’s searching for a solution) fixed that completely, as I verified by running 12 movies while rotating them on a 12-sided 3D surface (twelve times more amazing!). No crashes, no slowdowns. Things are smooth now.

I like Ubuntu because they seem to get at least part of the “big picture”—see, most Linux developers and hardcore users will point out feature-by-feature that Linux is better than or equal to Windows, MacOS X, and all other operating systems in existence. What they don’t get is that individual features don’t mean jack, it’s how they fit together that matters. If you’re missing one part of the puzzle, then people won’t care what other parts you got right. I think it’s important to understand that when making any software, but especially an operating system, whose job is by definition to integrate all the other parts.

Ubuntu at least begins to get this. They’re starting to bring things together through consistent visual design, consistent interface design, a complete suite of default applications, useful menus and preferences and utilities. They’ve also got some awesome 3D effects, but that wouldn’t matter much if there wasn’t any reason to use them.

So, in general, it’s finally a Linux I can imagine using every day. When I’m done with my work that requires Windows (what can I do, it’s corporate enterprise software…) I reboot and get into Ubuntu and for the first time in the history of my use of Linux, I don’t miss anything.

I think that’s a big deal. We’ve now got a community-built free OS that’s a real competitor to Windows and even OSX in some ways, and that’s a big accomplishment. More choices are always good for the user, and I’m finally a happy user with a great alternative to Windows.


This entry was posted on Friday, February 15th, 2008 at 8:27 pm and is filed under Life, Open-Source, Technical. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.


7 Responses to “Linux, take 14 (Ubuntu 7.10 Review)”



  1. nadavkav Commented at 10:22 am on February 16th 2008

    you are so true ! that is my experience too :-)
    that is way we have distributions for… to integrate a useful solution.

  2. steve Commented at 10:54 am on February 16th 2008

    yep, linux distros have come a LONG way – it’s very impressive. there’s still a lot of work to be done tho. when i installed ubuntu breezy badger on my laptop, it took me (a pretty tech-savvy guy) a few days to get wireless working. and once i got it working, it still involved editing the config files manually to change SSIDs and stuff..hehe. perhaps they’ve fixed this in the latest release?

    anyway, i eventually reverted back to windows so i could play Starcraft again :P i do regret it a bit, cuz windows just isn’t as smooth as linux.

  3. John X Public Commented at 5:23 am on February 18th 2008

    Why dual boot? use VirtualBox !

    apt-get install virtualbox

  4. Tristan Commented at 9:56 am on March 10th 2008

    Steve, you can totally play Starcraft in Wine! I remember doing that back in 1999, hehe. You’re right though, still can’t play the latest games and stuff. Cedega works well for that though if you want it.

    John – remember I’m a long-time Windows user (the kind who keeps their XP clean so it runs stable – since October 26th 2001 without a reinstall to be exact) and have a well-established existing installation. I don’t think I can take that and boot it into VirtualBox, but if I can please tell me!

    Also, an update on Wireless—we just got an Apple AirPort Extreme WAP (so my roommate can use remote Time Machine backups via NAS) and switched to WPA/WPA2 encryption, which is awesome, except the drivers for Linux aren’t liking it.

    Guess I spoke too soon about the Wireless issues being fixed. I think I’ll upgrade to the Hardy 8.4 alpha 6 release (or the beta that comes out on March 20th) and see if it’s any better, but I have a feeling I’ll have to use the now-shunned ndiswrapper to get it really working. :(

  5. Tristan Commented at 10:30 am on May 19th 2008

    Another update on the wireless – I booted into Ubuntu just the other day to do a ‘dd’ hard disk copy (laptop drive failed on me) and gave WPA2 another shot, and even with my weird wireless adapter, it magically just started working.

    I was in the middle of telling my roommate “yeah, it really sucks that WPA doesn’t work with this USB wifi adapter, but I might as well—oh—it does work. Go figure.”

    +1 for Ubuntu. I’m sure 8.04 will be even better, I’ll be updating soon.

  6. auto insurance toronto Trackbacked at 4:06 pm on August 29th 2008

    auto insurance toronto…

    rented alumni deepest cagers chants …

  7. property claims insurance Trackbacked at 6:19 am on August 31st 2008

    property claims insurance…

    pitches,leafing meddling:Heraclitus.wanting paunchy,...

Leave a Reply

Some XHTML allowed.